The Dive Otter

SAC vs RMV and Why?

Deep Dive on RMV Here and on SAC Here

WARNING-WARNING-WARNING
THIS DISCUSSION IS BY A RECREATIONAL DIVER FOR RECREATIONAL DIVING WITHIN RECREATIONAL LIMITS

Definitions...

SAC - Surface Air Consumption - Seems self explanitory but no. As one example, there is a 200 post argument on ScubaBoard about SAC and RMV..and that is just one forum post. In a basic form, it is the amount of air pressure you consume at the surface per minute using a specific size tank. Often incorrectly quoted as a particular number without the pressure units or the size of tank like "my SAC is 33" or "my SAC is .7". In the diving areas that use PSI it is assumed to be psi/min at the surface with an Aluminum 80 tank. Given SAC is used in math calculations, that is a signficant number of assumptions to take into account.
SAC is psi/min/ata and is cylinder dependent

RMV - Respitory Minute Volume - Sorta self explanitory and not widely known in the diving community. I have mentioned RMV to at least 20 different dive partners and a handful of instructors and none of them knew what it was. When they were mentioning a value that was technically RMV...they called it SAC. There are even dive computers that display SAC when it's actually RMV. Which confuses the hell out of people who know the difference between both. In a basic form, it is the volume of air consumed at the surface irrespective of tank size. In the diving areas that use feet it is assumed to be cubic feet per minute. Given the number does not care about tank size, it is better for use in math equations so conversion calculations do not have to occur when using different tanks.
RMV is cuft/min/ata and is cylinder independent

Tank Factor - In the Imperial world, the tank factor is the relationship between cubic feet and PSI. You can calculate a Tank Factor for any given tank by taking the Volume and dividing by the Pressure, which gives you the "Baseline" and then multiplying by 100 to give you the Tank Factor. An Aluminum 80 has a volume of 77.4 cuft and a working pressure of 3000 PSI. Which is a baseline of 0.026 and a Tank Factor of 2.580. Which means an AL80 has 2.58 cuft per 100psi. You can find the Tank Factor for various tanks online, you don't need to work it out yourself.

Assumptions...

....just use RMV to mean cuft/min and SAC for psi/min. And if someone says their [thing] is a number greater than 10..assume it's SAC. And if it's less than 10 (probably less than 1)..assume it's RMV.

How to calculate SAC...if you must

Quick and dirty method
([starting PSI] - [ending PSI]) / [dive time in minutes] / [average depth in atm] = SAC
(3000psi - 500psi) / 50min / 1.7atm = 29.41 psi per minute for whatever tank size you used

To use SAC on the fly in the future...you have to know the Tank Factors...and nobody wants to be carrying a conversion table around or doing maths in their head.

The way you are "supposed" to do it
Dive to a specific depth and stay at that depth for a specific period of time and swim around at that depth at a normal pace. This gives you a more accurate SAC. However, if you want to see improvement (or not) trends over time, the quick and dirty method is better as you can do it for every dive and sacrifice a little precision.

How to calculate RMV...and make the world a better place

Quick and dirty method
[starting PSI] - [ending PSI] * [Tank Factor / 100] = cubic feet consumed
[cubic feet consumed] / [dive time in minutes] / [average depth in atm] = RMV

3000 - 500 * (2.580 / 100) = 65 cuft consumed
(65cuft / 50min) / 1.7atm = 0.765 RMV

You have now created a universal number that doesn't require you to specify what size tank when talking to other people or when doing maths in the future.

Yes...but now what? How do I use it.

You can see if your air consumption is improving with experience like so...


Or even better...you can use it for Gas Planning of course