[ Scuba Diver Magazine Field Tests]
A Spare Air™ is nothing more than a low cost pre-configured Pony Bottle, so we can use one of the Minimum Reserve Gas calculations to determine if the Spare Air™ is a viable tool for scuba diving.
Since it is unrealistic that you will share a Spare Air™ in an emergency, we can assume this is for you only and not a buddy. To determine the gas we need for an emergency direct ascent we can use the Rock Bottom Gas calculation for one person under duress:
(1.0 RMV * Average Depth * Time of Ascent) = Cuft needed
Which Pony Bottle Do I Want?
Tank/Bottle | Price | Capacity | Max RBG Depth |
Spare Air™ 300 | $400 | 3 cuft | 15ft |
Spare Air™ 600 | $550 | 6 cuft | 30ft |
Standard AL13 | $850 | 13 cuft | 60ft |
Standard AL19 | $900 | 19 cuft | 75ft |
Standard AL30 | $950 | 30 cuft | 105ft |
Traditional AL40 | $1,000 | 40 cuft | 125ft |
Standard AL80 | $1,000 | 80 cuft | >130ft |
My Opinion
I just do not see how a tank smaller than 19cuft is viable as an emergency air supply. And given that Spare Air™'s largest tank they sell is 6 cuft...I can not in good conscious recommend one.