The Dive Otter

Canister Lights

[GUE - Positions | ISE - Opinion]

Canister lights, though more powerful and longer lasting, have an altogether greater risk to you the diver as well your buddy and, in my opinion, should not be used by 90% of recreational divers. It is an unnecessary risk.

The concern is primarily related to the length of the cord and how it interacts (tangles) with whatever hoses and equipment you also have.

Storage and Deployment

Excellent video from InnerSpace Explorers on the basics

The above requires considerably more situational awareness before and during the dive than using a hand-held light.

Expensive vs Less Expensive

From an industry perspective we can generally look at two options for a canister light. There are various different brands that sell expensive and less expensive options, but we'll use these two to compare.

OrcaTorch D630v2Halcyon Focus 2.0
Price$550$1,660
Max Lumens~4000~7000 (converted from Lux)
Beam AngleFixed 7 degreeAdjustable (~5 - 55 degrees)
Battery Size12Ah5.2Ah
Runtime on High5 hours2 hours
Runtime on ~1500 Lumens7 hours5 hours
On/Off SwitchPressMagnetic

On paper, the Halcyon is better. But is it ~$1,000 better? That's up to you.